The First Photo Won a Prize; The Second Made a Controversy Explode |

VERSIÓN EN ESPAÑOL

Controversy has erupted in Sweden with the photographer Paul Hansen’s image, which has won the Swedish Picture of the Year Award 2011, publishes Terra de España.

In the photo we can see Fabienne, a young Haitian girl of only 14 who was killed by the police after being discovered looting a store and stealing two plastic chairs and some framed artwork after the earthquake that shook Haiti.

image

(Photo Paul Hansen)

Now it is known that at the moment of this girl’s death, there were 14 photojournalists present, which has unleashed criticisms and a debate over the ethics of photographers.

The controversy began when the photographer Nathan Weber published a photograph where the same image appears as in the winning photograph but from a perspective in which the girl is seen laying on the ground, surrounded by photographers.

image

(Photo Nathan Weber)

The debate that is arising in Sweden revolves around the question, “Would Sweden have donated less for disaster relief if that photo had not been published?” Or “Would fewer resources and professionals have been sent?”



What do you think of the ethics behind this photograph? Which scene is more shocking? Which is more worthy of the prize?

 

 

  1. venuscreator ha reblogueado esto desde knowledgeequalsblackpower
  2. never-lock-the-door ha reblogueado esto desde politicaysociedad y ha añadido:
    white gaze.
  3. socialpants ha reblogueado esto desde politicaysociedad
  4. blackgirlsarefromthefuture ha reblogueado esto desde politicaysociedad y ha añadido:
    TRIGGER WARNING: Violence against Black Girls Again. There is a difference between allowing a Black girl to entertain...
  5. joyofbeing ha reblogueado esto desde manif3stlove
  6. still1984 ha reblogueado esto desde lavienoire y ha añadido:
    You are not entirely wrong. That one picture may very well not improve the situation of children like her. And, yes, to...
  7. lavienoire ha reblogueado esto desde still1984 y ha añadido:
    You know, I’m pretty sure YOU know nothing about detachment and being there and covering tragedies because of they way...
  8. fandomsandrubbish ha reblogueado esto desde cardozzza
  9. limenoc ha reblogueado esto desde politicaysociedad
  10. prettydiva8508 ha reblogueado esto desde cardozzza
  11. cardozzza ha reblogueado esto desde manif3stlove y ha añadido:
    There were fourteen grown adults present at the moment of her death, who because of their race and international status...
  12. hellolovesophie ha reblogueado esto desde politicaysociedad
  13. muzungus ha reblogueado esto desde thefemaletyrant
  14. manif3stlove ha reblogueado esto desde thefemaletyrant y ha añadido:
    Whoever wrote that long explanation. Sorry no. It’s 20-fucking 14. There are so many ways to spread information now....
  15. thefemaletyrant ha reblogueado esto desde still1984 y ha añadido:
    I honestly couldn’t make it past the first paragraph. To me there is no excuse and no justification. What good has come...
  16. urbnnerd ha reblogueado esto desde politicaysociedad
  17. meaningandhappiness ha reblogueado esto desde politicaysociedad
  18. karmapts ha reblogueado esto desde phenomenon-intervention
  19. madammemotoko ha reblogueado esto desde politicaysociedad
  20. excusable-charisma ha reblogueado esto desde politicaysociedad
  21. noabachelet ha reblogueado esto desde politicaysociedad y ha añadido:
    VERSIÓN EN ESPAÑOL Controversy has erupted in Sweden with the photographer Paul Hansen’s image, which has won the...
  22. unlearningeverything ha reblogueado esto desde stabra
  23. kiriko-kikuchi ha reblogueado esto desde ferrarisheppard y ha añadido:
    That photo of the WM photographers shooting (gross accidental pun) a recently shot-and-killed Haitian girl…. just too...
  24. kein-engel ha reblogueado esto desde ziplockandload
  25. umuziwezikhali ha reblogueado esto desde ferrarisheppard
  26. lordharrywhos ha reblogueado esto desde morningchai
  27. catnipcharge ha reblogueado esto desde hannahinreverie
  28. frederiksadones ha reblogueado esto desde politicaysociedad
  29. nipsndnaps ha reblogueado esto desde introspective-defects